DotNetKick.com is an open-source project. Please report any bugs and let us know your great suggestions. Currently running svn revision 620 (rss)

Kick Spy!, Kick Zeitgeist and Kick Widgets

20
kicks
Is MVC right for you?
published 11 months, 24 days ago, submitted by NikhilKothari NikhilKothari 11 months, 24 days ago

weblogs.asp.net — Interesting question... and interesting writeup ... asking if MVC is right for you. Will be an interesting discussion to follow no doubt.

Add a comment 6 comments | category: | Views: 2 | Get KickIt image code
tags: , | tag it

new Add a live kick counter to your blog >> liveImage

You can even customize the image by choosing your own colors, and then clicking the button below to update the preview and the html code:

  • "Kick It" text
  • "Kick It" background
  • kick count text
  • kick count background
  • border

Simply copy and paste this HTML into your blog post.


Users who kicked this story:
NikhilKothari NikhilKothari - simoneb simoneb - gavinjoyce gavinjoyce - davehogue davehogue - brianjlowry brianjlowry - powerrush powerrush - GTech33 GTech33 - crpietschmann crpietschmann - o2bjang - wwb_99 - Jemm Jemm - mghaoui - javierRomero javierRomero - EtienneTremblay EtienneTremblay - orca - gt1329a gt1329a - khushal999p - braddunbar - DrJazz - Reman

Comments:
Worst. Blog. Ever.

I have never seen anyone compare a language with politics. I am now dumber after looking at that blog.
posted by bladefist 11 months, 24 days ago
I used to do MVC with Java Servlets/JSP, and to some extent with ColdFusion (FuseBox). MVCs, indeed, have their own limitations/frustrations. It's nice to see a post regarding MVC that doesn't perpetuate the Web Forms such 100% and MVC rocks 100%.

Granted, I am happy to see that it seems MS is working towards making it easier to save state within forms and between forms -- that is one of the things that drew me to .NET from JSP.

It seems some people are throwing out the baby with the bathwater. And what's up with those that haven't even written an app in MVC saying that it's so great?!?

MVC has it's place and Web Forms have theirs.
posted by powerrush powerrush 11 months, 24 days ago
such = suck
posted by powerrush powerrush 11 months, 24 days ago
It's a little far reaching at points, but he makes valid points. I think a lot of us have been writing WebForms applications that mimic MVC's maintainability and well-defined separation of concerns all along. It always frustrates me to see people using WebForms poorly and then blaming the entire technology for their own shortcomings.
posted by gt1329a gt1329a 11 months, 24 days ago
my main point was the politics that are mentioned.
posted by bladefist 11 months, 23 days ago
"It always frustrates me to see people using WebForms poorly and then blaming the entire technology for their own shortcomings" - gt1329a

This is the same thing I heard when first comparing Classic ASP to ASP.NET. And, let us not forget there will be plenty of bad code written using ASP.NET MVC.
posted by crpietschmann crpietschmann 11 months, 23 days ago



information Login or create an account to comment on this story
 

Sponsored Link: www.carlist.ie

Search:

Ads via The Lounge

You are the editor:
View upcoming stories
Submit a story
How else can I help?
Earn money
Tags: all tags - your tags